How to create realistic bends n Poser figures.



  • To me, the thigh joint and the shoulder joint both present an issue with just about every rigging system.
    Tony mentioned that the thigh joint has to be in the right place. And that is true, only depending on how you rig it.
    Lets use the thigh as an example.

    The upper joint, and the center line of the bone (in a real person), don't line up.
    With standard rigging, the leg side to side may look right when you rig it.
    But when it is bent out to the side, is it still the right length?
    Too long, too short? Most likely, it is going to be one or the other depending on the Y center of the joint.
    The rigging system will change that as well.
    What about front to back? Hows the length then?
    There are tons of examples of how to rig a thigh out there, lots of figures to choose from.
    Different numbers of bones, etc.
    But how many of them, have the proper length when bent....
    Hmmm....

    Everyone that rigs, has a different style.
    This and many other threads, show that very well.
    It also shows the limitations in the rigging system being used.
    Just about every rigging system has trade offs.
    Throw a figure into different programs, and be basically the same in both?
    Well, Dawn did just that.

    Hivewire3D did an excellent job with Dawn.
    She continues to flourish in 2 different programs at the same time.
    And the key to that is bending as close as possible to itself, in different programs.
    And that, also corrolates to the joint centers.

    Rigging anything, is a system of trade offs.
    Rigging it to work in two different programs, have conformers work in both, etc, adds more trade offs.

    Throwing all these ideas around, is how we learn to get around them.

    One thing to remember.
    If I think I am right, does that make me wrong?
    Food for thought....



  • This is a very encouraging thread to read! I'm seeing all of the qualified assertions that indicate people are reading and understanding the necessary caveats others are expressing in this debate. Excellent!

    [Further, pages of commentary deleted when I realised I was just reiterating what others have already said ;-) ]

    I particularly appreciate @vilters concession that:

    A JCM is a very valid tool to "ADD" muscle movement that you can not get otherwise.
    Bones are as hard as , well, bones. They don't bend but break.
    Muscles tend to inflate or deflate during movement and are good JCM candidates.



  • @ken1171 I would like to also mention that vilters is demonstrating the exact opposite of the issue you are working to correct in your post. Your comments are about the thighs when they are used side-side in a crunching pose, NOT side-side in the splits.

    Dawn doing the side splits is an entirely different issue in clothing from Dawn crossing her legs in front of her. While it is the same joint rigging, it is entirely separated from Dawn's current thigh JCMs which work on the outer thigh only.



  • @glitterati3d An example of the difference with Dawn's JCMs and current rigging:
    0_1535374242092_DawnLegSide-Side1.jpg

    0_1535374262882_DawnLegSide-Side.jpg


  • Poser Ambassadors

    Your point must be that you can cover all up behind clothing?

    The prime of this tread was how you can improve bending by adding Dependencies Controlled Bending.
    => A procedure not very well known by most end users but it deviated into :
    We are discussing the position of Joint centers and to add JCM or not.

    Most content creators, not only for Dawn but also for PE are having the fights of their lives with JCM's, so the point is made.
    NEVER ever add a JCM in a rig to correct an unsatisfactory bend, but build and repair the rig properly and avoid rigging repair JCM's AT ALL COST.
    JCM's are for muscle movement, not for bone correction movements.

    • Ken builds JCM's to fight the existing JCM's.
    • I delete the JCM and repaint
    • Or you can hide the lot behind clothing

    Always multiple ways to Rome.



  • @vilters You are the one who brought Ken's thread into this discussion, even going on HW in his thread directing them back here.

    And, yet, you neglect to cover what Ken's thread is even addressing. And, then, try to pretend like I am the one changing the subject. Oooops, you actions betray you!


  • Poser Ambassadors

    This tread started with the best of intentions and turned into a very sensitive matter when joint positions and JCM's became the center of attention. Both issues are extremely closely related and each member reading the posts here and there understands the problematic and appreciates Pauls and Chris feedback.

    We managed to keep the tread polite and constructive, let us keep it this way. Thank you.



  • @vilters OK, then let's be productive.......you brought Ken's corrective morph work into the discussion. The specific morph work addressing the issue I showed examples of. Can you please address how your "magic" rigging resolves the work Ken is doing?



  • You all might want to consider that this little corner of the 3D universe is the only place that believes you can have a single figure with a single rigging that can be anything and everything. The major movie studios have dozens of rigs for each of their characters and use them for the movement types that are called for in the shot. Make a different version of the character and they make a dozen more rigs. possible.even remotely Until the programs get tot the point of having every muscle and tendon rigged and accounted for and clothing is no longer conforming then and only then is the discussion about realistic bending



  • @richard60 said in How to create realistic bends n Poser figures.:

    You all might want to consider that this little corner of the 3D universe is the only place that believes you can have a single figure with a single rigging that can be anything and everything. The major movie studios have dozens of rigs for each of their characters and use them for the movement types that are called for in the shot. Make a different version of the character and they make a dozen more rigs. possible.even remotely Until the programs get tot the point of having every muscle and tendon rigged and accounted for and clothing is no longer conforming then and only then is the discussion about realistic bending

    That's entirely different. They even rig stuff like the hair in some movies. They have special rigs that perform in special ways. While I'm not a proponent of the one figure to rule them all, for the most part Poser and Studio users are basically rendering stills, not animations.



  • @eclark1849 True while mostly it is stills we see the movement to get the character from a T pose to whatever they wish to portray it still has to move through various movement types and what may look good in one is off if you change the pose a couple of degrees and that is where having a Rig for certain movement positions becomes important.


  • Poser Ambassadors

    Just remember that saving/loading poses might not work after playing with dependencies!