New Figures for Poser any update?


  • Poser Ambassadors

    I really would like to know how AmbientShade and Ero's figures are coming along.

    Both so very promising, any updates guys?



  • @Biscuits Eros posts his progress at CGBytes. Don't know about Ambient Shade.



  • Since I postponed development of PE a few months back, much has improved:

    • Chuck fixed a bunch of issues with PP11, great!
    • I've practiced using PP11 and PP10 together on a small conforming figure I'm about to release
    • I've released a comic and making two new ones
    • I am leaving to the UK because the country I'm living in is going to hell...

    I am extremely eager to get working on PE again, and this time also complete it. Besides being eager, I also need to make it because comics alone will not help me survive in the UK. If PE goes well I will also make a dude (and a she-male version for the naughty fans).

    I will say I half expected there to be a new Poser figure out by now. Are Shade and I really the only two working on something? There must be more!

    PS: I am making loads of Poses for my comic character which shares the same rig as mesh5, so these I can also provide alongside PE when she comes out. I'll also try imitate most of the morphs I made for my comic character... and there are LOADZ!

    alt text


  • Poser Ambassadors

    @erogenesis
    There are more original figures in the works, like Ali's girl Bella (http://www.mankahoo.com/index.php?l=product_detail&p=37#)
    But it seems everyone wants it to be perfect and keeps working on it....



  • @wimvdb said in New Figures for Poser any update?:

    @erogenesis
    There are more original figures in the works, like Ali's girl Bella (http://www.mankahoo.com/index.php?l=product_detail&p=37#)
    But it seems everyone wants it to be perfect and keeps working on it....

    oh yeah I remember that one. It looked pretty good to me!


  • Poser Ambassadors

    Yay! Good news!
    Keep up the good work!


  • Poser Ambassadors

    Basically at this point, after spending a lot of time analyzing the current state of things, I don't see where any new figure can provide anything new over what V4WM, combined with a selection of various add-ons, already provides. This is the biggest reason why, in my opinion, none of the other various figures have caught on to any significant degree. Why invest in an entirely new wardrobe for a new figure that doesn't do anything substantially different than what is currently available?

    I could say a lot more but I won't publicly. I'll just wait to see what significant advancements, if any, Poser 12 offers to content creators.


  • Poser Ambassadors

    Shane is pretty spot-on. => NEW POSER FIGURES : Everybody ready? Because here we go.

    The same question was posed at Renderosity a few years back. I think we were in the "Alyson" and "Alyson2" period, where some individuals were also creating "new" Poser figures

    Alyson being ugly as hell, and not helped by her 42 magnet and JCM errors, the question for a new Poser figure was open.
    Then SM came with Miki4.
    Pffft, the same 42 and MORE JCM errors later the game was pretty much over. => those JCM's in Miki4, together with all her magnet and dependency symmetry errors made it close to impossible to build for her without loosing hair over the process.

    V4/M4 continued to grow over time, and each and every day, new and newer content kept feeding the mass public.

    Then came Rex and Roxie.
    Hey finally some better figures for Poser. I released some very-very popular clothing sets at Renderosity. Some of those can still be found in recent renders that pop-up left or right.

    But even with these "better figures" , the V4/M4 content kept overflowing the freestuff and marketplaces.

    Now we have Paul and Pauline, and forgive me, but I will take the freedom here to NOT talk about those 2 AT ALL.

    New Poser figures?
    Well, it is possible, but with a changed plan.

    At the time, I answered : if you build a new Poser figure, YOU and only YOU as the creator, can make YOUR figure popular by "AT LEAST" releasing 100 support items right from the start. YOU and ONLY YOU can make your own figure popular. And only AFTER YOU made YOUR figure popular, and the vendors see the opportunity, will they step in. If YOU as the creator are unable to make YOUR figure popular her life span is 3 to 5 days.
    That was 5 to 7 years ago?

    Nowadays, my answer would be : YOU have to be ready with AT LEAST 500 support items, right at release.
    Because by now in 2016 the V4/M4 have a more then 20.000 support item head start.

    Just try.
    Simply "just try".

    I have seen a few of the new figures, and they look WAY better then what we ever had in Poser. (At least some of those that I have seen are relatively error free, and easy to work with).

    What will KILL new figures at birth?

    • Not being symmetrical.
    • Dependencies.
    • JCM's. => God dammed => Learn how to paint a proper weight and bulge map. => If you "think" you need a JCM? => Think again.
      Change the obj file if required, change the Joints or weight and bulge maps. => ALL tools are good tools to avoid JCM's in a figure that you want to become popular.
      Those of us that went through the Alyson and Miki4 period => WILL push the delete button at first sight of a JCM. Any JCM, any reason. There IS not a single reason for a JCM => IN A STANDARD POSER FIGURE that you want to make POPULAR.

    You can build THE PERFECT figure. => If YOU are the only person to be able to work with her? You WILL miss the popularity train.

    All figures I have seen so far are better then what we have but :

    • Some will go down because => Too simple, but can be improved upon at end user level.
    • Some will go down because too complicated. => And these will go down first. => NO end user will start cutting up and deleting things because they mostly have no clue about "what's calling on what" to continue working.

    AmbientShade is correct.

    Something of a revolution is needed if "a" figure, any figure, would want to "start" to compete with the V4/M4.



  • PE would be my answer to your question of if a "new figure can provide anything new over what V4WM, etc, already provides". You are right that V4WM takes up 80% of the way, but there's definitely room for improvement. I could babble on about the usual like poly flow, rigging, xtra bones etc, but all these factors added together to add up in their increments to a more advanced figure. For example, my comic figure has certain body controls that I simply cannot do without anymore, and I reach for them automatically when I load up M4... they are so damned useful.

    And indeed, why bother with an entirely new wardrobe when you already have a working model system. This is what kept me going with V4 for so long. I hoped to achieve this with PE, namely keep V4 content going, but as you correctly pointed out I'll be heading for a mega lawsuit from DAZ probably. That in itself is a good enough reason to wanna break free and make a new figure...! The next best thing is converting all that stuff, which is what I'm attempting to make easier. But then there's also another thing: general improvements of models and content.

    One of the BIGGEST annoyances of most hair props and figures in almost all the stores, is that they are entirely stupidly unrealistic. They're either too poofy, too straight, or too extravagant, or too specific in styling to be of any use. 98% of my hair props/figures have been modified to look more real. DAZ vendors are improving gradually. Also with clothing and props, everyday poses and clothing are relatively rare and I struggle to get normal looking jeans and tops for my girls. This is kind of improving now.

    I think the world of CG figure content art is gradually maturing from the default "WOW its 3D" to looking beyond that and actually trying to achieve something artistic with it. Vendors cannot get away with making the same old crap anymore (since its all been done before and Poser allows you to tweak stuff) and need to get really smart with their products: ie: that its actually useful in a production environment, like extra morphs, useful poses, and origins in the right location!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! (ie around the hinges of a door and not in the middle).

    But then there's also another thing called "the dollhouse addiction" as i like to call it. Some people just like shopping, regardless of whether or not they really need it. I know folks in the Poserverse that will buy content, download it and even forget about it for several months! Poser is like a dollhouse hobby for some folks, buy a new dress and dress your dolly with it. What about a magical new girl??? But yeah, she does have to actually be magic, and not some incomplete sack of vertices that has the allure of a chewing cow.

    Of course at the end of the day its all about what you really want and need. Do you collect dolls? Are you a porn artist? Do you make forensic renders? Are you an illustrator? Or are you just having fun farting around with little people on your screen? I tailored PE for my own purposes, or at least that was the initial reason. And that is what I am sharing.

    Anyway I'm rambling...

    Back to my po*n!


  • Poser Team

    I welcome every new figure that comes to Poser, which ironically many do not. I don't want to be stuck with only a few figures, because when you do they inevitable all sort of look the same.

    The biggest issue I see with figures, is that more people bash them than help promote them. Let alone improve them.

    No figure will succeed with the constant bashing. None of them.

    Food for thought.


  • Poser Ambassadors

    JCMs are a necessity in Poser's rigging if you expect to have realistic joint bends. There is no getting around it. Even Genesis 3 has JCMs.

    I realize there are some rigging gurus that have found ways to avoid the use of JCMs but they haven't been done on a realistic figure, so it is irrelevant.

    The issue is how Poser handles JCMs and how complicated it is to create content that also incorporates those JCMs and makes the process as painless as possible for the supporting artist.

    And all of that is rather pointless without other more important features that can't be provided by the figure creator due to being limitations of the software itself. 3 of those features are correct geometry handling (broken welds), the lack of UV swapping, and the lack of sufficient geometry grafting. That's just a sample of what is lacking. All 3 of these features are made available in free software, yet still do not exist in Poser after years of being requested by content artists.

    When a figure artist cannot create a competitive figure because the tools to do so simply do not exist in Poser, it's a losing battle from the beginning. That figure will remain inferior to the 'competition' no matter how perfectly crafted it is.



  • @vilters said in New Figures for Poser any update?:

    • JCM's. => God dammed => Learn how to paint a proper weight and bulge map. => If you "think" you need a JCM? => Think again.

    Non. Njet. Nein. いいえ! Nietes. Neeeeeeen!

    With all respect, maybe I've misunderstood you somehow, but this is the one thing I flat out do not agree with you on. You quite simply, cannot, at all, achieve these bends using Poser's WM alone (see below). Impossible. Reason: you're limited to the plane of rotation, but flesh moves in all directions. Think folding knee, elbow, thigh, and they don't do it uniformly either. flesh compaction occurs only in the last few degrees. Even tendons you cannot simulate with WM. You need JCMs. You can get close using ghost bones or magnets that rotate outwards, I got close, but that opens up a whole new can of worms. My first version of PE was 100% WM, it was a nightmare for scaling! Also, why go through all that hassle when JCMs do it very simply, fast and effectively. Even G3 has craploads of JCMs and DAZ aren't stupid. Even some movie productions have used JCMs, 3D Max and Maya have those options too. I've worked with JCMs for years, with no problem at all. transfers to clothing without a hitch. I really don't see the problem. Sure, if you can do it with WM, good, but if a JCM will only help it look more realistic, then use it!

    Also please be careful with saying something like this. Some people might not be as knowledgeable about this like we are, and they'll take your word for it. Opinions like this could kill a very decent figure. Lali's Bits is 100% JCMs, and its sold thousands of copies, and its still selling. It makes V4 look good. This is the whole point about 3D figure art, to look good, its not some technical minimalist Mcgyver rally that sticks to duct-tape and matchsticks for the sake of traditional cardinal geometry feng shui.

    PE has plenty of JCMs, just like Lali's Bits, and if people are planning to trash it because of JCMs, then warn me now then I'll stop immediately.

    I say this with respect. I know you know your stuff, but this I don't agree with you on.

    alt text


  • Poser Ambassadors

    @erogenesis said in New Figures for Poser any update?:

    The next best thing is converting all that stuff, which is what I'm attempting to make easier. But then there's also another thing: general improvements of models and content.

    There are already a number of ways for the end user to convert existing content to a new figure. Wardrobe wizard, the fitting room, the morph brush, reshaping the clothing externally, etc.None of those methods have helped any of the new figures get off the ground. Because the majority of end users do not want to spend their time converting clothing. They want clothing that already works "as is", or with minimal to no effort.



  • @AmbientShade said in New Figures for Poser any update?:

    @erogenesis said in New Figures for Poser any update?:

    The next best thing is converting all that stuff, which is what I'm attempting to make easier. But then there's also another thing: general improvements of models and content.

    There are already a number of ways for the end user to convert existing content to a new figure. Wardrobe wizard, the fitting room, the morph brush, reshaping the clothing externally, etc.None of those methods have helped any of the new figures get off the ground. Because the majority of end users do not want to spend their time converting clothing. They want clothing that already works "as is", or with minimal to no effort.

    I agree, but I'm not saying that that is THE way, but that is the only way forward regarding one's existing library contents, if one doesn't want to invest in new items.... (or me getting sued to hell and back by DAZ)


  • Poser Ambassadors

    One way that could mitigate the issue of fitting old content to new figures would be if the fitting room used the same geometry and created a morph of that geometry with a new rig, instead of creating a duplicate with different grouping. This would allow anyone to create morphs for existing clothing and distribute those morphs without violating any copyright issues. So a figure artist could create a library of custom morphs for existing clothing to support their new figure, saving a ton of time in creating all new geometry. This of course would require issues already mentioned to be corrected in Poser before it could work.



  • @AmbientShade said in New Figures for Poser any update?:

    One way that could mitigate the issue of fitting old content to new figures would be if the fitting room used the same geometry and created a morph of that geometry with a new rig, instead of creating a duplicate with different grouping. This would allow anyone to create morphs for existing clothing and distribute those morphs without violating any copyright issues. So a figure artist could create a library of custom morphs for existing clothing to support their new figure, saving a ton of time in creating all new geometry. This of course would require issues already mentioned to be corrected in Poser before it could work.

    yep. If I understand you correctly, the only thing standing in the way of that is the segmentation of the mesh into bodyparts. Once Poser goes unimesh like max, C4D and Maya, this can easily be done. I believe Max and other apps already do something like that. you just slap some geometry that is roughly the same as the base mesh and the rig can be taken over, more-or-less. Is that what you mean?


  • Poser Ambassadors

    You are both correct.

    The massive mountain of content that the V4/M4 series have accumulated over the many years is the biggest problem for new figures.

    So, together with a "new" figure, you have to "invent" an easy way to convert that massive content without getting bitten by a lawsuit.
    This existing content also limits the freedom in figure size, vertex groups possibilities, rigging possibilities and so on.

    AmbientShade is right about the many tools Poser has to convert stuff, but from the past we also know that most end users simply wanna "load, pose and render". I also see that AmbientShade is thinking about distributing? DAZ does not even allow shrinkwrapping, so...

    The hobby guy that has a single free hr a day for his hobby, (and that is the majority of home alone end users) wants to end that hr with a render.
    And if he/she has a free hr a week? He/she spends most of that free hr on : "How did I do that last time?"

    Ero?
    You are certainly making the "best possible figure out there", but probably also the most complicated, and that is a little bit of what I am scared off.

    You 2 are posting as I type so... LOL.

    Yeah, you can get new geometry, and then a new rig, and then a new UV_Map, euh?.... What's left of the original?



  • @vilters the whole point of PE was for me to get on with telling stories. in other words, PE does 90% of the work already with her WM and JCMs and morphs. So it should be good. For vendors it should also be ok. I have tried to avoid bulges where I can and the JCMs will be clearly labelled. The mannequins will also help do the work for them.

    There are only two things complicated about PE and that is 1. the way she was made, and 2. her shoulders. Thankfully the way she was made will only be evidenced by my bitter whining an complaining in various forums across the Poserverse. But her shoulders might be the toughest thing to sell. Many people are used to crappy figures that allow you to throw the shoulders up into the air without a thought. problem is that shoulders cannot go that high in reality. Try touching your ear with your shoulder, while keeping your arm down, and not bending your head towards it. Impossible. The only way to get your shoulder that high is to twist the whole region backwards. The scapula actually rotates all the way down (I never knew that!) You can see this when you reach for the sky and see that your armpit is now facing forwards. In PE this basically translates to: shldr Fw, collar twist up (with a few other small rotations). Try selling that to the Poser crowd.

    To solve this I have dials to control that specific movement for the user, but I might even have to make a video about it.


  • Poser Team

    This might sound like a really odd question.
    But why are you using the fitting room at all?

    I also don't see the return on investment of making a morph set so you can use on other figures as a vendor either. Doing so instantly limits the customer base too people that not only have that content, but actually use it as well. Just because something sold a lot, doesn't mean it will get used a lot today either.

    I don't use the fitting room to refit clothes in most renders.
    Simply because it does all the things that everyone mentioned. To me the fitting room is useful for some things, but using content once or twice for a render has much easier ways of going about it. The fitting room is basically just a new set up room with more options that have come into Poser since the original set up room which is still there.

    All of you know that I have been playing around with Pauline Advanced for a while now.
    And it might surprise you to know that fitting room got very little use in the process.

    Pauline Advanced comes with one of the files you need to do so as well.

    I will leave the rest of that, as food for thought.



  • @shvrdavid Exactly! As long as every new figure is a bash fest, NO ONE is going to release them.

    Why would you? So strangers can savage your model, your reputation and your business?


Log in to reply
 

Looks like your connection to Graphics Forum was lost, please wait while we try to reconnect.